Chinese Swimmer's Record Raises Doping Concerns - The New York Times
The New York Times
Olympics |China Pool Prodigy Churns Wave of Speculation
Search
Continue reading the main story
Photo
The Chinese swimmer Ye Shiwen, 16, is one of the youngest competitors in the Olympics and so far the most remarkable. Credit Doug Mills/The New York Times
LONDON — At 16, the Chinese swimmer Ye Shiwen is one of the youngest competitors in the Olympics and so far the most remarkable. What she has done in the pool is the water-based equivalent of what Usain Bolt did on the track four years ago in Beijing.
On Saturday night, Ye not only shattered the world record in the 400 individual medley, winning gold in 4 minutes 28.43 seconds, she also swam the final 50 meters faster than Ryan Lochte did in winning the men’s race. On Monday, Ye returned to the pool and set an Olympic record of 2:08.39 in the semifinals of the 200 individual medley, her best event.
There is nothing to indicate that she is anything more than a great swimmer from a country that holds about a fifth of the world’s population, a teenager who relies on the latest scientific training and the kind of adolescent certainty that makes her unaware of any limitations. The Chinese have pledged to obey the rules. And Ye dismissed any concerns about doping.
Yet women’s swimming does not permit itself naïve and untempered adulation. Not after the systematic East German doping of the 1970s and ’80s. Not after Chinese scandals in the 1990s. Not after Michelle Smith of Ireland won four medals at the Atlanta Games in 1996 under disputed circumstances and was later barred from competition for tampering with a urine sample.
The response to unsurpassed achievement now falls somewhere uncomfortably between amazement and incredulity, that gray area between celebration and suspicion.
Advertisement
Continue reading the main story
“That’s pretty unbelievable,” David Sharpe, a Canadian swimmer, said of Ye’s finishing kick on Saturday, in which she covered her final 50 meters in 28.93, faster than Lochte’s 29.10. “No one really understands how that happened.”
Ye swam her final 100 meters of the 400 I.M. in 58.68 seconds. Lochte was only three-hundredths of a second faster. No one could immediately remember a woman closing faster than 61 seconds.
“Interesting,” said Natalie Coughlin, an American with 12 Olympic medals.
“Insane,” said Stephanie Rice of Australia, the 2008 Olympic champion and former world-record holder in the 400 I.M. “Fifty-eight is out of control.”
Lochte made a cordial joke about being outkicked. On Monday, Michael Phelps, who finished fourth in the men’s 400 I.M., smiled at a question about Ye’s closing speed and said: “She almost outswam me, too. We were all pretty shocked. It’s pretty impressive that she went that fast.”
No swimmers accused Ye, who is 5 feet 8 inches and weighs 141 pounds, of using illicit substances to fuel her kick. Medalists and, at random, other athletes are tested at the Games.
But John Leonard, an American who is executive director of the World Swimming Coaches Association and has long voiced suspicions of doping in China, told The Guardian on Monday that he found Ye’s performance “disturbing.”
Caitlin Leverenz, an American who finished third in Ye’s heat in the 200 on Monday, said: “The Chinese have had a history in the past of doping, so I don’t think people are crazy to point fingers, but I don’t think that’s my job to do right now. I’m just trying to do my best.”
Photo
Ye Shiwen, 16, of China in the 200-meter individual medley, July 30. Credit Doug Mills/The New York Times
Frank Busch, national team director for USA Swimming, was more gracious, calling Ye’s final 100 meters on Saturday “more than remarkable, phenomenal.”
Advertisement
Was he concerned that what Ye had done was not legitimate?
“I would never go there,” Busch said.
Instead, he mentioned Bolt of Jamaica, who had seldom run 100 meters before the 2008 Beijing Games but shattered records in the 100, the 200 and the 4x100-meter relay. There must be room left, Busch suggested, for success built solely on talent, coaching, ambition and the wonder of youth.
Please verify you're not a robot by clicking the box.
Invalid email address. Please re-enter.
You must select a newsletter to subscribe to.
Sign Up
Privacy Policy
“These kids work really hard,” he said. “I don’t know what the Chinese are doing. But I don’t think anybody saw Usain Bolt running that fast in 2008.There are times you have phenoms coming up that surprise you with what they can do.”
Busch did not mention her name, but Janet Evans was once one of those phenoms. At the 1988 Seoul Olympics, Evans, then 17, outswam even the East Germans and won three gold medals. She was fully embraced, while Ye faces public skepticism. Many will find that unfair. Perhaps it is.
Yet China has brought uncertainty upon itself. Ye has never tested positive for banned substances. But in the 1980s and ’90s, according to news accounts, more than 50 Chinese swimmers did. Seven were caught by a surprise test at the 1994 Asian Games in Hiroshima, Japan. One swimmer, Yuan Yuan, was caught with 13 vials of human growth hormone at the 1998 world championships in Perth, Australia.
There has long been debate about whether doping in China was state-sponsored or directed by individual coaches. A former chief doctor for the Chinese gymnastics team told The Sydney Morning Herald last week that in the 1980s, it was state-sponsored.
Some say embarrassment over doping scandals led China to scrutinize its athletes more carefully. In any case, the dominance of China’s female swimmers in the mid-1990s has ebbed. China won only one gold medal in swimming at each of the past two Olympics, including the 2008 Beijing Games.
Already, it has won two in London. This follows a recent report by the official Xinhua News Agency that in March, a 16-year-old swimmer named Li Zhesi, a former relay champion, tested positive for the blood-boosting drug EPO. Though Ye’s achievement may once have brought only commemoration, it now comes with questions.
According to state-run news outlets, Chinese coaches and athletes have taken an oath to remain clean. Some athletes are even said to be avoiding meat, fearing it might be tainted with a banned substance, clenbuterol.
“There’s absolutely no problem with doping,” Ye said Monday in translated remarks. “The Chinese team has always had a firm policy about antidoping.”
Advertisement
Continue reading the main story
Ye began swimming at 7 and was placed in a sports school in Hangzhou in eastern China. By 14 she began making national and international waves. Last year, Ye won a world title in the 200 I.M. She has also trained in Australia, where Chinese swimmers say they are free from grinding monotony.
“In China, we are always used to just train, train, train, study, study, study and get some rest,” said Lu Ying, who won a silver medal Sunday in the women’s 100 butterfly. “Our way of thinking has many limits. And we are bound by them. But in Australia, I can be invited to a barbecue or a breakfast. In China that never happens.”
Ye has repeatedly said hard work, not a banned substance, has made her a champion. “If the coach asks me to practice 10,000 meters,” she told The Beijing Morning News, “I would never be lazy to swim 9,900 meters instead.”
A version of this article appears in print on July 31, 2012, on Page A1 of the New York edition with the headline: China Pool Prodigy Churns Wave of Speculation. Order Reprints | Today's Paper | Subscribe